Federal Judge Calls Prediction-Market Bettors “Suckers,” Highlights Fee-Sharing Model
Judge Colleen McMahon called Novig bettors “suckers,” saying the platform charges fees to two users, recalling her 42-month Craig Carton sentence and 2018 Supreme Court reversal of 1990s sports-betting ban.

- Judge Colleen McMahon called Novig users “suckers” in a court filing.
- Novig earns money by charging a fee to each of the two users who bet against each other.
- McMahon previously sentenced Craig Carton to 42 months in federal prison for a fraud tied to his gambling debts.
- The filing was reported on 12 November 2026.
What happened
The filing was reported on 12 November 2026.
Federal Judge Colleen McMahon wrote a court filing concerning Novig, a prediction-market platform backed by Sydney Sweeney. In the filing she called the platform’s users “suckers.” She stated that Novig earns money by charging a fee to two users who bet against each other.
McMahon was appointed to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York by President Bill Clinton in the late 1990s.
The federal government prohibited state-sanctioned sports betting in the 1990s and the Supreme Court struck down that prohibition in 2018. A Kentucky lawmaker described all sports bettors as “suckers,” and Warren Buffett has used similar language to refer to gamblers.
Polling indicates many people believe sports betting is skill-based, yet the text calls viewing prediction markets as an “investment” absurd and observes that most sports bettors lose money over time, whether betting with a house or peer-to-peer. Individuals who develop problem gambling should seek support or therapy.
The details that matter
Judge Colleen McMahon’s familiarity with gambling-related fraud dates back to a 42-month federal prison sentence she imposed on former WFAN personality Craig Carton. Carton’s conviction stemmed from a multimillion-dollar fraud scheme that was directly linked to his gambling debts, underscoring the judge’s experience with the financial fallout of compulsive wagering.
The Novig filing spells out the platform’s exact revenue mechanism: a fee is levied on each of the two users who place opposite bets. That charge applies regardless of which side wins, embedding a cost into every transaction and turning the peer-to-peer market into a fee-sharing operation.
The filing also calls the notion that prediction markets are “investments” absurd. That judgment mirrors a broader observation that most sports bettors lose money over time, whether they wager with a traditional house or through a peer-to-peer exchange.
Language around problem gambling is highlighted as counterproductive. Referring to individuals with gambling addictions as “suckers” does not help those struggling, and the author notes that people who develop problem gambling should seek support or therapy.
While the term may describe the structural dynamics of a fee-charging platform, the author concludes it is unsuitable when applied to the individuals caught in the cycle.
- ‘Suckers’ — Federal Judge Slams Prediction Market Sports Bettors - GamblingHarm.org