New Jersey petitions Supreme Court over sports-event swaps, experts anticipate nuanced split
Eleven amicus briefs support New Jersey’s petition after a Third Circuit win and Ninth and Sixth Circuit losses; a definitive ruling may not arrive until August 2027.
On Sept. 2, New Jersey asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review the Third Circuit’s April ruling in Flaherty v. Kalshi EX, seeking a decision on whether contracts that swap a sporting event’s financial outcome are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act or state-regulated sports bets.
- The Third Circuit ruled in favor of Kalshi.
- The Ninth Circuit ruled against Kalshi.
- Eleven amicus briefs, including those from former Senator Chris Dodd and former CFTC Chair Gary Gensler, support New Jersey’s petition.
- Sanchez Guarda estimates the earliest definitive Supreme Court ruling could be August 2027.
What happened
New Jersey filed a petition with the Supreme Court on Sept. 2, asking the high court to review the Third Circuit’s April ruling in Flaherty v. Kalshi EX. The Third Circuit had ruled in favor of Kalshi, while the Ninth Circuit and the Sixth Circuit had ruled against the firm.
Eleven amicus briefs were filed to support New Jersey’s request. Former Senator Chris Dodd filed a brief in August, arguing that the Third Circuit’s reading was wrong. Former CFTC Chair Gary Gensler filed a brief stating the CFTC never sought to become a national gambling regulator. The NFL submitted a brief proposing a middle ground that would allow hedging contracts but bar individual player-activity calls. Former CFTC special counsel Peter Sanchez Guarda warned the Court could issue a split decision, permitting some sports contracts while banning others.
Stephen Piepgrass, a partner at Troutman Pepper Locke, told SBC Americas the case is now closer to the high court but still requires briefing and oral argument. Kalshi founder Tarek Mansour said he expects the dispute to reach the Supreme Court, though he did not predict an outcome on the Reuters Econ World podcast.
The legal question centers on whether sports-event contract swaps fall under the Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC jurisdiction or are regulated as state and tribal sports bets. The CFTC issued an October rulemaking proposal that defines event contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather as swaps, and Piepgrass said the timing was intended to bolster the agency’s exclusive authority. Most states set the sports-betting age at 21, while Kalshi allows 18-year-olds to trade.
The DeFi Rate litigation tracker counts 155 U.S. prediction-market legal matters, including 141 lawsuits. The Supreme Court hears about 60-70 cases per term out of thousands of petitions, and the prediction-market cases are not among those announced for this term. Sanchez Guarda estimates the earliest definitive ruling could be August 2027; Bill Pascrell III described the process as a “slow roll” and does not expect a ruling within 12 months. Several gambling-sector attorneys said the Court could take the case up next summer.
The details that matter
The report, dated 16 Nov 2026, notes that New Jersey’s petition asks the high court to decide whether contracts that swap the financial outcome of a sporting event count as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act or as state-regulated sports bets.
Sanchez Guarda argues that contracts tied to the Super Bowl are “defensible” because the game’s result directly drives merchandise sales, broadcast-rights revenue and ticket sales. Those downstream economic effects give the contracts a hedging character that distinguishes them from pure wagering.
By contrast, in-game wagers on individual pitches lack that economic linkage. Guard cites CFTC Core Principle 3, which bars contracts that are essentially gambling rather than bona-fide risk-management tools, suggesting such bets could be prohibited.
The split rulings remain: the Third Circuit’s favorable decision for Kalshi stays in place, while the Ninth and Sixth Circuits’ adverse judgments continue to govern their jurisdictions. The distinction therefore affects Kalshi’s 18-plus traders, state-licensed sportsbooks limited to 21-year-olds, the NFL, tribal regulators and the CFTC.
Sanchez Guarda estimates the earliest definitive Supreme Court ruling could arrive by August 2027.