Novig sues Ohio, says CFTC rule makes state betting ban unconstitutional
The claim, filed Nov. 16 in federal court, marks Novig’s seventh Ohio lawsuit after the state sent cease-and-desist letters to eight firms and a September Sixth Circuit decision against Kalshi.

Novig filed a federal suit on Nov. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, naming Ohio’s Attorney General, the Ohio Casino Control Commission and its interim executive director Andromeda Morrison as defendants. The company argues the state’s sports-betting statutes are “discriminatory and preempted” after a CFTC interim rule labeled sports-event contracts swaps, a stance the court must now confront.
- Novig filed the lawsuit on Nov. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio.
- Ohio is the seventh state Novig has sued since launching its prediction market platform in August.
- The OCCC sent cease-and-desist letters on Oct.
What happened
Novig filed a federal lawsuit on Nov. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, naming Ohio’s Attorney General and the state gaming regulators as defendants. The complaint targets the Ohio Casino Control Commission (OCCC) and its Interim Executive Director Andromeda Morrison, alleging that the state’s “discriminatory and preempted” sports gambling laws violate the U.S. Constitution.
Novig’s federally licensed designated contract market, Ludlow Exchange, LLC, argued that the Commodity Exchange Act and recent CFTC rulemaking preempt Ohio’s enforcement actions.
The suit follows a September decision by the Sixth Circuit in KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler, which held that federal commodities law does not preempt state sports-betting statutes even if the contracts qualify as swaps. Novig contended that the ruling is unsettled because a petition for rehearing en banc and three certiorari petitions remain pending before the Supreme Court.
Novig also borrowed Polymarket’s “interstate commerce” argument, claiming Ohio’s requirement that operators have an in-state place of business forces a fundamental change to its business model.
The filing marks Novig’s seventh lawsuit against Ohio since it launched a near-nationwide prediction-market platform in August, joining earlier actions by Kalshi, Polymarket and Underdog.
The details that matter
The notice declares sports-event contracts to be swaps, while the interim rule simultaneously says casino-style products are not swaps, a clash Judge Colleen McMahon described as “inherently contradictory.”
Ohio’s regulator treats any sports-event contract offered without a state license as illegal online sports gambling. The OCCC warned that firms continuing the activity could face criminal prosecution and insisted that operators either maintain an in-state place of business or contract with an Ohio-based proprietor - requirements Novig says would force a fundamental redesign of its platform.
On Oct 2 the OCCC dispatched cease-and-desist letters to eight prediction-market operators, including Coinbase, Robinhood and Underdog, bringing the total of companies under warning to ten. Coinbase and Robinhood complied, pulling their sports contracts from Ohio in exchange for a regulator pledge not to enforce state gaming statutes while their appeals are pending; Underdog had already sued the state in September.
The Sixth Circuit’s late-September ruling against Kalshi, which held that federal commodities law does not preempt state sports-betting statutes even if contracts qualify as swaps, remains intact.